MONUMENT BLOG
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Resources
  • Nomadic Memorial

Offense

8/26/2015

 

On June 17th, Dylan Roof ended the Bible-study meeting at Emanuel AME Church in Charleston by killing nine people.  He was introduced to the world by his blog on the following day.  Along with a manifesto, Roof – a millennial – filled his website with self-portraits.  His favorite props were guns and the Confederate battle flag.

In the two months since, governments and corporations have reacted with surprising speed to shun Confederate symbols.  T-shirts featuring the flag are no longer allowed on eBay.  Warner Brothers will not manufacture toy models of the General Lee.  Most impressively, South Carolina’s Stars and Bars were removed (twice) from the State Capitol.

The Confederacy’s memorials will be the next to go.

In state houses across the South, the process of removing Confederate monuments from public landscapes has begun.  General Forrest and the Confederate Every-man are unwelcome on campus and in the park.  Their statues are stained with graffiti: #BLACKLIVESMATTER; THE CAUSE FOR WHICH THEY FOUGHT – THE CAUSE OF SLAVERY – WAS WRONG; THIS IS RACIST; KKK; MURDERER.

The graffiti is right, but the city councils are wrong.  Terrorized by the loss of innocent black lives to vigilantes and trigger-happy cops, progressives are seeking relief in the wrong place: the censorship of public art.

In an eerie coincidence, plans to scrub pro-Confederate art from the public realm are beginning to echo instances on the opposite side of the world.  In March 2001, the Taliban removed two 1,500 year-old Buddha sculptures from the cliffs of Bamiyan with artillery rounds.   In the US, online petitions seek to eliminate a bas-relief sculpture of Confederate heroes from Stone Mountain in Georgia.  If the petitions are successful the monument is destroyed, probably with dynamite. What are the implications of adopting the Taliban's tactics in an American dispute over art?

The destruction of Confederate memorials seems justifiable because the American South is still haunted by ghosts of the C.S.A.  The threat of violence is still real, so its monuments are still unsettling.  So unsettling, that blowing up a few memorials is starting to seem like a good idea to southern progressives.  

Confederate memorials do pose some serious problems. They are in the middle of an ugly process - the transition from “hate speech on public land” to “government curated artifact.”  Many of them were built during the peak of Jim Crow oppression. They were 50% memorial & 50% not-so-coded-message that this community does not welcome black people.  

Still, it sets a troublesome precedent to take them down.

Can an inclusive society demolish sculptures that represent a conservative minority’s view of history? Must all publicly-owned art represent a government’s present point of view?  What will be left of free speech if every generation destroys that which offends it? What contemporary memorials will our great-grandchildren raze in disgust?

Confederate memorials must be endured.  The cost of censorship is too high. 

Also, a better opportunity exists. Progressives now have the political capital to do what they do best: Speak. Create.

Now is the time to douse statues with graffiti; to write protest songs; to build new monuments that confront the old ones.

Now is the time to build a memorial for the nine that died at Emmanuel AME. It's time to update Nathan Bedford Forrest’s memorial in Memphis, pointing out his role in the early KKK.  It's time to express, in bronze and in stone, society’s rejection of racial profiling.

Let folks nostalgic for the 1860’s have their sacred public spaces and their mythologies.  Let them feel that their First Amendment rights are respected. The value of allowing Confederate memorials to stand is in letting them show us just how far away we are from celebrating the Confederacy.

Rick link
7/21/2016 10:29:47 pm

This is such a provocative topic. I can understand African-Americans would be disgusted by reminders of (and celebration of!) the terrorism they endured throughout this country's checkered history. I was reminded of this when I read some material from a group called the Equal Justice Initiative. In addition to their advocacy for social justice in our prison system, they're working to counteract some of those more questionable monuments. They take a positive approach by commemorating the victims of that violence.

1) They've put up markers about the slave trade around Montgomery AL: http://www.eji.org/raceandpoverty/slaveryinamerica

2) They have a "remembrance project" to honor lunching victims: http://www.eji.org/eji-soil-collection-lynching-remembrance-july-30 and http://www.eji.org/node/1179

3) They're planning a Montgomery memorial to all lynching victims: http://www.fastcoexist.com/3056859/this-stunning-national-memorial-would-recognize-americas-legacy-of-lynchings

Perhaps this positive approach addresses the problem better than destroying public monuments. On the other hand, maybe it's not enough. I honestly don't know if it would be enough for me if I were a black man.

Thanx, Matt, for bringing this important topic to light.


Comments are closed.

    Author

    Matt Sickle is a landscape architect living in Maryland, near Washington, D.C.

    He spends a lot of his time thinking about monuments and memorials.  

    Archives

    January 2021
    October 2020
    June 2020
    December 2019
    September 2019
    October 2018
    December 2016
    March 2016
    August 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014

    Categories

    All
    9/11 Memorial
    American Veterans Disabled For Life Memorial
    Bladensburg
    BLM
    Canada
    Censorship
    Central Park
    Charlottesville
    Confederate Memorials
    FDR Memorial
    Fujifilm Quicksnap
    Ground Zero
    Irish Hunger Memorial
    Kodak Funsaver
    Landscape Architecture
    Lincoln Memorial
    MLK Jr. Memorial
    Monument Walk
    National Mall
    New York City
    Polaroid
    Veterans Memorial
    WWI Memorial

Copyright ©2010-2020 Matt Sickle.  Neither text nor images may copied, printed or otherwise used without his written permission.